John Gill's Bible Commentary Ver. 1. Now when Jesus was born , etc.] Several things are here related respecting the birth of Christ, as the place where he was born, in Bethlehem of Judea ; so called to distinguish it from another Bethlehem in the tribe of Zabulon, ( Joshua 19:15). Here Christ was to be born according to a prophecy hereafter mentioned, and accordingly the Jews expected he would be born here, ( Matthew 2:4-6 John 7:41,42) and so Jesus was born here, ( Luke 2:4-7) and this the Jews themselves acknowledge; Such a year, says a noted chronologer of theirs, Jesus of Nazareth was born in Bethlehem Juda, which is a parsa and a half, i.e. six miles, from Jerusalem.
Benjamin Tudelensis says it is two parsas, i.e. eight miles, from it; and according to Justin Martyr it was thirty five furlongs distant from it. Yea even they own this, that Jesus was born there, in that vile and blasphemous book of theirs, written on purpose to defame him; nay, even the ancient Jews have owned that the Messiah is already born, and that he was born at Bethlehem; as appears from their Talmud f63 , where we meet with such a passage. It happened to a certain Jew, that as he was ploughing, one of his oxen bellowed; a certain Arabian passed by and heard it, who said, O Jew, Jew, loose thy oxen, and loose thy ploughshare, for lo, the house of the sanctuary is destroyed: it bellowed a second time; he said unto him, O Jew, Jew, bind thy oxen, and bind thy ploughshare, for lo ajym aklm dyly the king Messiah is born. He said to him, what is his name? Menachem (the comforter); he asked again, what is his fathers name? Hezekiah; once more he says, from whence is he? He replies hdwhy jltyb aklm tryb m from the palace of the king of Bethlehem Judah; he went and sold his oxen and his ploughshares, and became a seller of swaddling clothes for infants; and he went from city to city till he came to that city, (Bethlehem,) and all the women bought of him, but the mother of Menachem bought nothing.
Afterwards they tell you, he was snatched away by winds and tempests.
This story is told in much the same manner in another of their writings.
Bethlehem signifies the house of bread, and in it was born, as an ancient writer observes, the bread which comes down from heaven: and it may also signify the house of flesh, and to it the allusion may be in ( Timothy 3:16) God manifest in the flesh. The time of Christs birth is here expressed, in the days of Herod the king . This was Herod the great, the first of that name: the Jewish chronologer gives an account of him in the following manner. Herod the first, called Herod the Ascalonite, was the son of Antipater, a friend of king Hyrcanus and his deputy; him the senate of Rome made king in the room of Hyrcanus his master. This Herod whilst he was a servant of king Hyrcanus (so in the f67 Talmud Herod is said to be anwmj tybd adb[ a servant of the family of the Asmonaeans) king Hyrcanus saved from death, to which he was sentenced by the sanhedrim of Shammai; that they might not slay him for the murder of one Hezekiah, as is related by Josephus, l. 6. c. 44. and Herod took to him for wife Miriam, the daughter of Alexander the son of Aristobulus, who was the daughters daughter of king Hyrcanus.
This writer tacitly owns afterwards that Jesus was born in the days of this king; for he says, that in the days of Hillell and Shammai (who lived in those times) there was one of their disciples, who was called R. Joshua ben Perachiah, and he was, adds he, yrxwnh wbr the master of the Nazarene, or of Jesus of Nazareth. Herod reigned, as this same author observes, thirty seven years; and according to Dr. Lightfoots calculation, Christ was born in the thirty fifth year of his reign, and in the thirty first of Augustus Caesar, and in the year of the world three thousand nine hundred and twenty eight, and the month Tisri, which answers to part of our September, about the feast of tabernacles; which indeed was typical of Christs incarnation, and then it may reasonably be thought that the word was made flesh, and eskhnwsen tabernacled among us, ( John 1:14). Another circumstance relating to the birth of Christ is, that when Jesus was born behold, there came wise men from the East to Jerusalem ; these wise men in the Greek text are called magoi , Magi, a word which is always used in a bad sense in the sacred writings; hence they are thought by some to be magicians, sorcerers, wizards, such as Simon Magus, ( Acts 8:9) and Elymas, ( Acts 13:8) and so the Jewish writers interpret the word wgm a wizard, an enchanter, a blasphemer of God, and one that entices others to idolatry; and in the Hebrew Gospel of Munster these men are called ypkm wizards. Some have thought this to be their national name. Epiphanius supposes that these men were of the posterity of Abraham by Keturah, who inhabited a country in some part of Arabia, called Magodia: but could this be thought to be the name of their country, one might rather be induced to suppose that they were of the magoi , Magi, a nation of the Medes mentioned by Herodotus f71 ; since both the name and country better agree with these persons; but the word seems to be rather a name of character and office, and to design the wise men, and priests of the Persians. An Eastern writer says the word is of Persic original, and is compounded of two words, Mije Gush, which signifies a man with short ears; for such was the first founder of the sect, and from whom they were so called. But in the Arabic Persic Nomenclator it is rendered a worshipper of fire, and such the Persian priests were; and to this agrees what Apuleius says, that Magus, in the Persian language, is the same as priest with us: and Xenophon says, that the Magi were first appointed by Cyrus, to sing hymns to the gods, as soon as it was day, and to sacrifice to them. The account given of them by Porphyry is, that among the Persians they that were wise concerning God, and worshipped him, were called magoi , Magi, for so Magus signifies in their country dialect; and so august and venerable were this sort of men accounted with the Persians, that Darius, the son of Hystaspis, ordered this, among other things, to be inscribed on his monument, that he was the master of the Magi.
From whence we may learn in some measure who these men were, and why the word is by our translators rendered wise men; since the Magi, as Cicero says, were reckoned a sort of wise men, and doctors among the Persians: who further observes, that no man could be a king of the Persians before he understood the discipline and knowledge of the Magi: and the wisdom of the Persian Magi, as Aelianus writes, among other things, lay in foretelling things to come. These came from the east , not from Chaldea, as some have thought, led hereunto by the multitude of astrologers, magicians, and soothsayers, which were among that people; (see Daniel 2:2,10,27 4:7) for Chaldea was not east, but north of Judea, as appears from ( Jeremiah 1:14,15; Jeremiah 4:6) ( Jeremiah 6:22 Jeremiah 10:22 Jeremiah 25:9). Others have thought they came from Arabia, and particularly Sheba, induced hereunto by ( Psalm 72:10,15). But though some part of Arabia lay east, yet Sheba was south of the land of Israel, as is evident from the queen of that place being called the queen of the south, ( Matthew 12:42). The more generally received opinion seems to be most right, that they came from Persia, which as it lies east of Judea, so was famous for this sort of men, and besides the name, as has been seen, is of Persic original. The place whither they came was Jerusalem, the metropolis of Judea, where they might suppose the king of the Jews was born, or where, at least, they might persuade themselves they should hear of him; since here Herod the king lived, to whom it seems they applied themselves in the first place. The time of their coming was, when Jesus was born; not as soon as he was born, or on the thirteenth day after his birth, the sixth of January, as it stands in our Calendar; or within the forty days before Marys Purification; since this space of time does not seem to be sufficient for so long a journey, and which must require a considerable preparation for it; nor is it probable if they came so soon as this, that after such a stir at Jerusalem, after Herods diligent search and inquiry concerning this matter, and his wrath and anger at being disappointed and deluded by the wise men, that Joseph and Mary should so soon bring the child into the temple, where, it was declared to be the Messiah by Simeon and Anna. Besides, immediately after the departure of the wise men, Joseph with his wife and child were ordered into Egypt, which could not be done before Marys Purification.
But rather this their coming was near upon two years after the birth of Christ; since it is afterwards observed, that Herod sent and slew all the children that were in Bethlehem, and in all the coasts thereof, from two years old and under, according to the time which he had diligently inquired of the wise men, ( Matthew 2:16). This was the opinion of Epiphanius formerly, and is embraced by Dr. Lightfoot f80 , to whom I refer the reader for further proof of this matter.
Matthew Henry Commentary
Verses 1-8 - Those who live at the greatest distance from the means of grace ofte use most diligence, and learn to know the most of Christ and his salvation. But no curious arts, or mere human learning, can direct me unto him. We must learn of Christ by attending to the word of God, as light that shineth in a dark place, and by seeking the teaching of the Holy Spirit. And those in whose hearts the day-star is risen, to giv them any thing of the knowledge of Christ, make it their business to worship him. Though Herod was very old, and never had shown affectio for his family, and was not himself likely to live till a new-bor infant had grown up to manhood, he began to be troubled with the drea of a rival. He understood not the spiritual nature of the Messiah' kingdom. Let us beware of a dead faith. A man may be persuaded of man truths, and yet may hate them, because they interfere with his ambition, or sinful indulgences. Such a belief will make him uneasy and the more resolved to oppose the truth and the cause of God; and he may be foolish enough to hope for success therein.
Greek Textus Receptus
του 3588 T-GSM δε 1161 CONJ ιησου 2424 N-GSM γεννηθεντος 1080 5685 V-APP-GSM εν 1722 PREP βηθλεεμ 965 N-PRI της 3588 T-GSF ιουδαιας 2449 N-GSF εν 1722 PREP ημεραις 2250 N-DPF ηρωδου 2264 N-GSM του 3588 T-GSM βασιλεως 935 N-GSM ιδου 2400 5628 V-2AAM-2S μαγοι 3097 N-NPM απο 575 PREP ανατολων 395 N-GPF παρεγενοντο 3854 5633 V-2ADI-3P εις 1519 PREP ιεροσολυμα 2414 N-ASF
Vincent's NT Word Studies
1. Bethlehem. Hebrew, House of Bread, probably from its fertility. The birthplace of him who calls himself the Bread of Life (John vi. 35), and identified with the history of his human ancestry through Ruth, who was here married to Boaz, and was the ancestress of David (i. 5, 6), and through David himself, who was born there, and anointed king by Samuel (compare Luke ii. 11, city of David).Wise men, or Magi (magoi). Wycliffe renders kings. A priestly caste among the Persians and Medes, which occupied itself principally with the secrets of nature, astrology, and medicine. Daniel became president of such an order in Babylon (Dan. ii. 48). The word became transferred, without distinction of country, to all who had devoted themselves to those sciences, which were, however, frequently accompanied with the practice of magic and jugglery; and, under the form magician, it has come to be naturalized in many of the languages of Europe. Many absurd traditions and guessed respecting these visitors to our Lord's cradle have found their way into popular belief and into Christian art. They were said to be kings, and three in number; they were said to be representatives of the three families of Shem, Ham, and Japhet, and therefore one of them is pictured as an Ethiopian; their names are given as Caspar, Balthasar, and Melchior, and their three skulls, said to have been discovered in the twelfth century by Bishop Reinald of Cologne, are exhibited in a priceless casket in the great cathedral of that city.
Robertson's NT Word Studies
2:1 {Now when Jesus was born} (tou de iesou genneqentos). The fact of the birth of Jesus is stated by the genitive absolute construction (first aorist passive participle of the same verb gennaw used twice already of the birth of Jesus, #1:16,20, and used in the genealogy, #1:2-16). Matthew does not propose to give biographic details of the supernatural birth of Jesus, wonderful as it was and disbelieved as it is by some today who actually deny that Jesus was born at all or ever lived, men who talk of the Jesus Myth, the Christ Myth, etc. "The main purpose is to show the reception given by the world to the new-born Messianic King. Homage from afar, hostility at home; foreshadowing the fortunes of the new faith: reception by the Gentiles, rejection by the Jews" (Bruce).
{In Bethlehem of Judea} (en beqleem tes ioudaias). There was a Bethlehem in Galilee seven miles northwest of Nazareth (Josephus, _Antiquities_ XIX. 15). this Bethlehem (house of bread, the name means) of Judah was the scene of Ruth's life with Boaz (#Ru 1:1f.; Mt. 1:5) and the home of David, descendant of Ruth and ancestor of Jesus (#Mt. 1:5). David was born here and anointed king by Samuel (#1Sa 17:12). The town came to be called the city of David (#Lu 2:11). Jesus, who was born in this House of Bread called himself the Bread of Life (#Joh 6:35), the true Manna from heaven. Matthew assumes the knowledge of the details of the birth of Jesus in Bethlehem which are given in #Lu 2:1-7 or did not consider them germane to his purpose. Joseph and Mary went to Bethlehem from Nazareth because it was the original family home for both of them. The first enrolment by the Emperor Augustus as the papyri show was by families (kat' oikian). Possibly Joseph had delayed the journey for some reason till now it approached the time for the birth of the child.
{In the days of Herod the King} (en hemerais herwidou tou basilews). this is the only date for the birth of Christ given by Matthew. Luke gives a more precise date in his Gospel (#Lu 2:1-3), the time of the first enrolment by Augustus and while Cyrenius was ruler of Syria. More will be said of Luke's date when we come to his Gospel. We know from Matthew that Jesus was born while Herod was king, the Herod sometimes called Herod the Great. Josephus makes it plain that Herod died B.C. 4. He was first Governor of Galilee, but had been king of Judaea since B.C. 40 (by Antony and Octavius). I call him "Herod the Great Pervert" in _Some Minor Characters in the New Testament_. He was great in Sin and in cruelty and had won the favor of the Emperor. The story in Josephus is a tragedy. It is not made plain by Matthew how long before the death of Herod Jesus was born. Our traditional date A.D. 1, is certainly wrong as Matthew shows. It seems plain that the birth of Jesus cannot be put later than B.C. 5. The data supplied by Luke probably call for B.C. 6 or 7.
{Wise men from the east} (magoi apo anatolwn). The etymology of Magi is quite uncertain. It may come from the same Indo-European root as _(megas) magnus_, though some find it of Babylonian origin. Herodotus speaks of a tribe of Magi among the Medians. Among the Persians there was a priestly caste of Magi like the Chaldeans in Babylon (#Da 1:4). Daniel was head of such an order (#Da 2:48). It is the same word as our "magician" and it sometimes carried that idea as in the case of Simon magus (#Ac 8:9,11) and of Elymas Barjesus (#Ac 13:6,8). But here in Matthew the idea seems to be rather that of astrologers. Babylon was the home of astrology, but we only know that the men were from the east whether Arabia, Babylon, Persia, or elsewhere. The notion that they were kings arose from an interpretation of #Is 60:3; Re 21:24. The idea that they were three in number is due to the mention of three kinds of gifts (gold, frankincense, myrrh), but that is no proof at all. Legend has added to the story that the names were Caspar, Balthasar, and Melchior as in _Ben Hur_ and also that they represent Shem, Ham, and Japhet. A casket in the Cologne Cathedral actually is supposed to contain the skulls of these three Magi. The word for east (apo anatol"n) means "from the risings" of the sun.